Before Winter Break: A Midyear Student Progress Checklist
ByThe Cub Guide Team · November 16, 2026 · 6 min read
By mid-November, many students have been in their fall interventions for eight to ten weeks. That's enough data to see a trend, and there's still time to change course before January. It's why so many Student Assistance Teams (SATs, also called SST or problem-solving teams) pack their calendars between Thanksgiving and winter break.
The meetings that go well tend to look alike: the data is gathered before anyone sits down, the team compares progress to a goal, and everyone leaves knowing what happens next. This checklist helps you get there.
The midyear checklist
1. Gather behavior ratings and trends
Pull the student's daily behavior ratings since the start of the year, not just last week. A daily behavior report card turns a vague impression ("he's been better lately") into a line you can point to.
2. Compare academic progress to the goal line
For each academic skill, put the scores next to the goal. NCII describes this step plainly: once enough data are collected, they are graphed and evaluated against the student's goal to decide whether progress is sufficient.
3. Check whether interventions happened as planned
Before deciding an intervention isn't working, confirm it was delivered. The Center on MTSS highlights implementing interventions as intended, and monitoring that fidelity, as part of sound data-based decision making.
4. Collect teacher observations
Numbers tell you what changed, and comments tell you why. Ask every adult who works with the student for two or three short notes: what's working, what's hard, and when.
5. Look for patterns by time and day
Check attendance and look at ratings by class period and day of the week. A rough Monday or a hard stretch after recess often points to a simpler fix than a new intervention.
6. Decide: fix delivery, continue, adjust, intensify, or fade
- Fix delivery first when fidelity was low, then re-check before changing the plan.
- Continue when the trend is heading toward the goal.
- Adjust when progress is flat but the intervention was delivered well.
- Intensify when the gap is growing. NCII's Taxonomy of Intervention Intensity offers dimensions like dosage and alignment to guide the change.
- Fade when the student has met the goal consistently.
See the Taxonomy of Intervention Intensity for more detail.
7. Set the next review date and owners
Every decision needs a name and a date. Pick the next review (often 4–6 weeks out) and write down who is responsible for each change.
8. Share a summary with families
PBIS.org describes families and school staff working together and sharing responsibility for educational decisions. Share a short, plain-language summary with one graph, and invite the family's input before the next review.
A simple 30-minute agenda
- Goals and current data (5 min)
- Intervention fidelity check (5 min)
- Teacher observations and patterns (10 min)
- Decision and changes (5 min)
- Next review date, owners, and family summary (5 min)
Running the meeting in Cub Guide
We built Meetings in Cub Guide so the team doesn't have to bounce between a notes doc and a stack of printouts. The Meetings panel opens right above the student's Behavior and Academic Trends, so you record notes while the data stays on screen.
Each saved meeting appears as a marker on the trend charts, next to the goal line. At the next meeting, you can see what changed since the last decision.
When the meeting ends, the goals in place that day are saved with the summary, along with what to continue, what to adjust, and when the team meets again. Later goal changes never rewrite that history.
Checklist recap
- Behavior ratings and trends since the start of the year
- Academic scores compared to each goal line
- Confirmation that interventions happened as planned
- Two or three notes from every adult involved
- Patterns by class period, day of week, and attendance
- A decision: continue, adjust, intensify, or fade
- Next review date and named owners
- A short family summary with one graph
New to the framework? Our MTSS guide covers tiers, progress monitoring, and decision rules in more depth.